Tag Archives: Allopathic Medicine vs. Holistic Medicine

Preventive Medicine- it is not just taking supplements

heart preventive medicine

Too many people including healers think and believe that the term preventive medicine is taking supplements and other alternative treatments. Health is so much more then all the latter: The responsibility should be shared by the client and the healer whether s/he be in traditional medicine or alternative-complementary-holistic medicine.

I was not planning on writing on this topic but a situation came up. Two very close people to me went for a complete physical and came back feeling quite secure when the doctor reported to each of them that their health was good except that the sonogram showed mild fatty livers in each of them. No surprise since each of them drinks quite a bit. There were other discrepancies when I reviewed the laboratory reports but that is not an issue in this writing.

I will return to the above after my soliloquy on preventive medicine or the lack of it. For quite sometime now it has been obvious to me that it is easier for myself and the client to prevent illnesses rather then try and cure them. Obviously, it is also a lot cheaper for the individual and the insurance companies (but the opposite for the pharmaceutical companies). A mostly healthy life style is the way to live with exercise, live food and stress reduction activities. I say a mostly healthy life style because I find two things with being too strict with ourselves and my clients. One, too strict and the majority will give up their good intentions after a short time of doing what “the doctor ordered.” Two, there is a certain amount of fun in life that we want to have and some of these involve deviating from the path of towing the “gotta do this always for my health”. Three, but really true and important, is I find a lot of “health freaks” become neurotic over every thing they do so they will not get ill. Of course, the latter can lead to stress and can be a sickness in itself. Trying to be completely health-wise in a non-healthy world leads to stress, and stress I believe to be the main cause of disease. Therefore, a self defeating life style There is a possible four, which is what is stated today as the most healthy thing you should do to stay healthy may be proved wrong tomorrow. This is true also for so many pharmaceuticals. I can write a book and not a blog on these but you will come across many in my book and blogs. For now let us just take the example of aspirin which was pushed for so long even though doctors and the FDA knew it was a major cause for bleeding ulcers and its complications like death. Now the AMA is stating not to use it unless you have a cardiovascular condition. But if one believes that today’s health theory may change tomorrow, then one would do nothing to help themselves stay healthy. So lets not go along with that but just note it since one would have to read and study each scientific research article and who did the research to know if something was good or bad and then keep up with current advice about it. Let us hope that reading things like this will give the reader more forethought about spending money because it is advertised as being the health panacea.

So we follow a moderately healthy life style and then have to decide which supplements are best for us as individuals. First we must realize that supplements are just that – supplements. They are not a substitute at all for healthy, natural vitamins, minerals, proteins and healthy fats (omega 3s, mono and polyunsaturated fats and some moderate cholesterol intake. (See my blog A Word about Cholesterol). Then we have to watch our pocketbooks, and importantly who is toting the supplement that is the panacea to health. A supplement company should be able to produce a written document on their quality control system and of the item you desire. Another thing I have found that in general the supplements of pharmacies are not as good as those from a reputable company. for example, One-A-Day vitamins. There is no way that a vitamin taken once a day will have the healthy requirement of your body needs. To get the quantity of minerals and vitamins requires 3-4 capusles in the AM and 3-4 at night (in general). The one a day do not have enough for a gerble.

For instance, there are so many health drinks advertised that supposedly stop all ailments and give longer life (anti-aging) with the proof that such and such indigenous people use it. of course they do not state the life-style of these people which probably is different then the western life style. Seems we are back to the “snake-oil” days, but at least snake-oil usually had laudanum in it, an opiate. Well how about saving money and eating healthy food. The idea that a supplement cost more is better then ant-oxidants in live food to me is ludicrous. Ah, but then some people say “I use it and can see the difference.” Maybe they can because they are not getting it from their daily eating habits. Or, it could be the placebo effect which I have experienced with so many clients in my 40 years of medicine. Nothing wrong with the placebo effect. In fact, it is great if the person feels better and is really getting better and not masking an illness. This health expenditure holds true with all the plastic bottled water that people are consuming. Most of them will not make you healthier and some will actually have a long term negative affect on the body such as an electrolyte imbalance and the phthalates out gassing estrogen mimickers from the plastic. Use the Internet before thinking this advertised health water is good for me; do your own research, but not with advertisements. Unfortunately most municipal water tastes bad and is also polluted with “healthy ingredients” (sarcasm)

OK, Back to preventive medicine and the starting paragraph. This deviates from the way a lot of laypeople and healers view preventive medicine. We have a doctor reporting to clients (I dislike the word patient) that they have good health except for mild fatty livers. They go away confident that they are in good health except for the mild fatty liver. Wrong!! They are ill with a serious pathology. Now is the time to tell them this and for the physician and client to start healing the liver and causes before it progresses to the next stage. This is preventive medicine! The term border line disease is a disaster. The person needs health now. To me, it is like telling a woman you are a little bit pregnant. You are either pregnant or not.

A person comes in with a blood sugar that is in the very high normal range. It should signal the physician that another test should be done to check why this is and not say it is still in the normal range. I get a fasting insulin along with the fasting sugar. If the fasting insulin is high that is a signal that there is a problem. Because the body will try to keep homeostasis (equilibrium) so the pancreas keeps putting out more and more insulin to get rid of the excess sugar either by forcing it into the cells or detouring it into fat (triglycerides). So the sugar looks within the normal “boxes” but only due to this compensation. Now is the time for the physician to treat the person so their sugar and insulin go down. Not when the overworked pancreas can no longer make insulin. Not when the person has symptoms and signs of insulin resistance, diabetes or the metabolic syndrome. This would be preventive medicine!

A woman comes in with the following symptoms and signs: cold when others are comfortable, lose of head hair and the outer 1/3 of her eyebrows, constipation, fatigue, gaining weight but working out, dry skin and her temperature is less then 96.4 Her lab reports (thyroid stimulating hormone=TSH) show that her thyroid is functioning within the normal range. So what! she is giving the classic symptoms and signs of hypothyroidism or/and adrenal fatigue. This should be followed up by the physician with further thyroid tests. Some holistic physicians would start treating this as hypothyroidism on a low dose (I hope natural) thyroid medicine. Then watch the client, get further tests and a better history especially about the family. This is preventive medicine! Not saying well it is not your thyroid since the labs are normal and putting the woman on menopausal pharmaceuticals and an antidepressant.

Prevention is not treating lab work as if it is the patient, but rather listening to the client’s symptoms, signs, history, using what the physician was trained to do. Think about the differential diagnosis; a list of diseases that it could be since the symptoms and signs are similar in so many diseases. Then treat the client and not the laboratory report. Explain to the client what the healers thought process is and get feed back from the client. The client too must take responsibility for getting and staying healthy. It is the patient teaching the physician and the physician teaching the client. The healer should be there as a teacher and as a life guard when necessary.

Emotional Vampires and Your Hormones: an holistic physician’s view of how stress affects your well-being and what you can do about it.


The Antibiotic Controversy

antibiotic controversyHaving been in medicine more then 45 years of which 25 of these in Holistic Medicine. I find there are a few thoughts that are being disregarded on the topic of antibiotics by both healers and the general public.  As an holistic MD I am against the indiscriminate use of antibiotics as has been done in the past and still persists in the present despite all the AMA warnings, but at least to a significantly lesser degree . As a rational and past ER MD I know that “to throw the baby out with the bath water” is as narrow minded and dangerous as the allopathic physicians’ negative view of the use and consideration of alternative-complimentary medicine.

People that have experienced life threatening illnesses such as mesenteric gangrene, or a burst appendix, felon of the finger or sepsis, etc. have appreciation for the antibiotic use. There is a place for the emergent use of antibiotics but not their abuse as history has presented to us. A simple UTI can be handled with colloidal silver IV &/or mannitol; but as a learned MD I do not want to put the client at risk of the possible sequel of glomerulnephritis or pyelonephritis and therefore an avoidable hospital admission & the consequences of an iatrogenic infection (and hospital food). If I use an antibiotic I double the dose (AM &PM) of the probiotic while on it and keep the client on this for a minimum of 30 days after the antibiotic course. Hopefully my clients take a probiotic every day for all their life.

For 25 years I have been successful treating advanced infections with the IV use of colloidal silver &/or H202, &/or high dose Vitamin C. Always with discretion & discussion with the client. I rarely use antibiotics but as stated when I believe it is necessary I discuss this choice with the client and explain why I believe it is necessary. I use IV therapy with my holistic choices since many people have dysbiosis or leaky gut syndrome and will not absorb via treatments done orally. This way I know my alternative treatment is in their blood and going to the infection or inflamed pathology. I have for example used colloidal silver IV and H202 IV to cure the flu in12-36 hours. There is a place for all our knowledge in healing when used correctly. The treatment must fit the individual client and disease and not just be a standard textbook treatment.

I suggest to people that they have a list of questions for their physician-client interaction because so often people are intimidated or nervous and forget what they wanted to ask. The physician should take the time to explain the answers to the client and having a list should make this an easier task for the healer.

Yes, there could be side affects to any pharmaceutical but also to alternative-complimentary therapies. There are also side effects of any serious pathology like sepsis or neurocyticercosis (a parasitic infestation of the brain) when not being treated with antibiotics. The side effects without proper antibiotics of some terrible diseases is death or disability. There are so many illnesses and diseases with similar symptoms and signs that it takes a lot of education for an MD, DO or ND to learn what is called the differential diagnoses (DD), or at least to know where to look for them,  when to look for them and when to refer. The DD cannot be learned in a 1-2 year alternative course. There are long residencies so the physician can actually see these diseases and keep learning from other experts. Continuous education for licensed MDs, DOs and NDs is very stringent and monitored. After all this education I believe the healer is ready to make a decision whether to use and practice alternative-complimentary therapies or allopathic or both together. At least the previous education gives the choice and knowledge to the healer to discuss options with the client as a partnership.

Be aware that my statements in no way are my feelings of support for the big pharmaceutical conglomerates; their villainous prices in the USA (compared for the same pharmaceuticals in other countries), their ways of advertising both via the media and to physicians. My opinions are only my very long experience of learning in both fields of medicine. I feel It is the physician teaching the patient and the patient teaching the physician.

But “do not throw the baby out with the bath water.”